Compare and contrast two examples of brief therapy Essays

Compare and contrast two examples of brief therapy Essays Compare and contrast two examples of brief therapy Essay Compare and contrast two examples of brief therapy Essay called The Skilled Helper Model . Harmonizing to Egan ( 1990 ) this provides one manner of analyzing a patient s job to let the originative production of alternate solutions. This theoretical account is non so much a specific method of transporting out therapy as an overall theoretical account of the assisting procedure. What Egan ( 1990 ) provides is a model within which a healer or counselor can work. The theoretical account breaks down the assisting procedure into three phases. The first phase involves the healer pointing themselves within the patients universe, to get down happening out what is traveling on. Egan ( 1990 ) farther interrupt this down into three different phases. The first phase involves the healer promoting the patient to state their narrative by utilizing active hearing and oppugning to arouse all the relevant inside informations. It is here at the first phase that a clear contrast can be seen with the SFBT which does non supply much focal point on the geographic expedition of the job Egan s theoretical account is acute to prosecute with the exact dimensions of the job. The 2nd portion of the first phase involves placing any blindspots or parts of the patients narrative which have non been sufficiently investigated. As everyone has their ain peculiar beliefs and premises about the universe, the theoretical account s method encourages the patient to research th emselves from a more nonsubjective point of view. Harmonizing to Egan ( 1990 ) it will frequently be that there are many facets of themselves that people are non cognizant of. To a certain extent, this will affect soft challenging of the patient to assist them get at a wider point of view. This provides a 2nd contrast to SFBT which is non truly concerned with disputing the patient s point of view, as its focal point is more solution-orientated. The 3rd portion of the first phase is in concentrating down onto which peculiar country the patient would wish to concentrate on in their therapy. It may be that through doing a alteration in one country of their life, good effects will be seen in other countries as good. Egan ( 1990 ) negotiations of placing those concerns, concerns, or even chances, that will do a difference to the patient. This may affect make up ones minding what would hold the greatest knock-on effects, or what it is possible to accomplish at the minute. Again this 3rd p ortion of the first phase provides a contrast to SFBT as it is still centred largely on the different jobs that the patient has. The 2nd phase in the skilled assistant theoretical account, as explained by Egan ( 1990 ) , is promoting the patient to visualize a better hereafter for themselves. The purpose of this procedure is to clear up ends and to supply motive. Again, this phase is broken down into three parts. The first portion is where the healer encourages the patient to visualize a solution province to their job. The patient is helped to be originative in the manner they solve their job, non to be constrained by practicalities. The 2nd portion involves conveying in the practical facets of the end and seeking to make something that can truly be achieved. Egan ( 1990 ) besides suggests that the end should be in line with the patient s values, represent a good manner of turn toing the identified job, be possible within a period of clip and be realistic. The 3rd portion of this 2nd phase involves the healer in proving with the patient whether the motive is at that place or non. And if it is non, so ways need to be examined for happening the motive or doing other alterations to the ends. The 2nd phase of the skilled assistant theoretical account appears to come closer to SFBT as it is concentrating on the solution. In peculiar, both therapies focus on holding a vision of how things might be in the hereafter. The skilled assistant theoretical account, nevertheless, topographic points more accent on the input of the healer as a moderator for the patient, the healer in a SFBT session will merely admit the patient s pick, compliment it and travel on to turn to it. The 3rd phase of the skilled assistant theoretical account involves working out precisely how the client will acquire from the current state of affairs to the end that they have envisioned. Again, this phase is broken down into three parts. First, the patient is asked to brainstorm for schemes the accent at this phase being on thought as widely and creatively as possible. Again, the 2nd portion involves contracting these schemes down to take the most appropriate. The pick of scheme may be limited by the patient s frame of mention and so the healer is encouraged to assist the patient get as near to their end as possible. Finally in the 3rd portion, the patient is encouraged to turn the peculiar scheme that has been chosen into a concrete, bit-by-bit program. Egan ( 1990 ) explains that this is done by interrupting down the scheme into its constituent parts and so attaching a time-frame to each action. With the accent in the 3rd phase of the skilled assistant theoretical account on the building of a solution, this is possibly the closest in spirit and method to SFBT. This 3rd phase besides emphasises the importance of leting the patient to make their ain decisions with the healer merely steering the manner, a similar attack to that used in SFBT. A hunt of the psychological databases for research on the rating of the skilled assistant theoretical account reveals that little or no research specifically on this theoretical account has been carried out. This is likely because of the generalization of the theoretical account, the trouble of make up ones minding on appropriate result steps and really mensurating any results that are decided on. This so provides a farther contrast between the two types of therapy, in that SFBT has some positive grounds in the peer-reviewed literature to back up its usage, while the skilled assistant theoretical account largely because of its nature has little. Some other, more general contrasts can be drawn between the two types of therapy. In SFBT, the healer is most interested in making a vision for the hereafter and believes that the seeds of this vision are contained in the patient s current behavior. These can be brought out by concentrating on the behavior and what the patient feels is required in order to make their vision. In this manner SFBT is highly forward looking, with the healer passing about all the reins to the client. Crucially, the healer tends to concentrate on conveying out the positive facets that the patient is attesting in any possible manner. In contrast, the healer in the skilled assistant theoretical account looks rearward every bit good as forward, and provides a much greater grade of counsel to the patient through the procedure. Egan ( 2002 ) is acute to indicate out that the skilled assistant theoretical account is merely one manner of looking at the procedure and the phases of the therapy should be used flexib ly and in this sense it is a higher degree and less specific signifier of therapy than SFBT it is possibly better seen with the accent on model instead than the more specific techniques that are contained within SFBT. Mentions Cockburn, J. T. , Thomas, F. N. , Cockburn, O. J. ( 1997 ) . Solution-focused therapy and psychosocial accommodation to orthopedic rehabilitation in a work indurating plan. Journal of Occupational Rehabilitation, 7 ( 2 ) , 97-106. de Shazer, S. ( 1985 ) . Keys to Solutions in Brief Therapy. New York: Norton de Shazer, S. ( 1988 ) Hints: Investigating Solutions in Brief Therapy. New York: Norton. Egan, G. ( 1990 ) The Skilled Helper: a Systematic Approach to Effective Helping, 4th edition, Monterey, CA, Brooks/Cole Egan, G. ( 2002 ) The Skilled Helper: a problem-management and chance development attack to assisting, 7Thursdayedition, Brooks/Cole: Pacific Grove, CA. Gingerich, W. J. Eisengart, S. ( 2000 ) Solution-Focused Brief Therapy: A Review of the Outcome Research, Family Process, 39 ( 4 ) 477 Iveson, C. ( 2002 ) Solution-focused brief therapy. Progresss in Psychiatric Treatment vol. 8, pp. 149–157 Lindforss, L. , Magnusson, D. ( 1997 ) Solution focussed therapy in prison. Contemporary Family Therapy 19, 89-103 Zimmerman, T. S. , Jacobsen, R. B. , MacIntyre, M. , Watson, C. ( 1996 ) . Solution focused rearing groups: An empirical survey. Journal of Systemic Therapies, 15 ( 4 ) , 12-25.